‘Make America Nice’ Meets Brass Knuckles

Name tag on a pinstripe suit jacket pocket
Photo: W. Scott McGill / Shutterstock

Democrats spent tens of millions of dollars on attack ads this year while rolling out a brand new slogan: “Make America Nice Again.”

Quick Take

  • Some Democrats are testing a 2028 message built around “decency” and unity after big midterm wins.
  • Axios found Democratic-aligned ads still spent tens of millions of dollars attacking Republicans.
  • Negative, anti-system ads from Democrats jumped from 19 in past cycles to 47 this year.
  • Trump’s low approval rating and cost-of-living anger, not niceness, drove most of the wins, experts say.
  • Many races from November remain too close to call, muddying any claim of a clear mandate.

A New Slogan Born From Big Wins

Democrats flipped more than 40 Republican-held House seats in the 2026 midterms, taking back control of Congress in states like North Carolina, Pennsylvania, Texas, and even deep-red Kentucky. Riding that momentum, some Democrats now want to brand the party as warm and welcoming for 2028. Ohio’s governor-elect, Amy Acton, put it simply: “basic decency is on the ballot”.

The theory goes like this: voters got tired of nonstop political warfare and wanted something calmer. Some Democratic strategists believe the public “soured on Trump-style, scorched-earth political warfare” and craved politics that felt “nicer and more optimistic”. It’s a tidy story. The only problem is the receipts don’t match the rhetoric.

The Ad Spending Tells a Different Story

An Axios review of more than 350 campaign ads found Democratic and Democratic-aligned groups ran 47 ads this cycle built on harsh, anti-party or anti-system attacks. That’s up from just 19 in 2024 and 2022, and 14 back in 2018. Meanwhile, positive ads promising bipartisan cooperation collapsed from 45 in 2024 down to only 18 this year. The party talked unity. The money said something else entirely.

Politico reported Democratic campaigns poured roughly $36 million into ads centered on the Jeffrey Epstein scandal alone, turning it into shorthand for corruption attacks on Republicans. Even candidates who branded themselves as decent and unifying, like Acton, still ran tens of millions in negative ads against their Republican opponents once their races tightened. Conservative commentators were quick to point out the obvious contradiction between the “nice” branding and the brass-knuckles tactics backing it up.

Voters Were Angry at Trump, Not Charmed by Democrats

President Trump’s approval rating sat at just 38% heading into the election, and 89% of voters called the cost of living a major or crucial factor in their vote. NBC News described the results as largely driven by opposition to Trump’s policies, not by any newfound love for Democratic decency. That matters because it means Democrats may be reading far too much into a win that had almost nothing to do with their messaging.

Several races from the midterms were still unprojected weeks later, with exact House and Senate margins unsettled. A fuzzy outcome makes it even harder for Democrats to claim a clean mandate for any new slogan, let alone one their own ad spending contradicts. Voters weren’t necessarily buying “niceness.” They were punishing a president they blamed for high prices, and Democrats just happened to be standing there.

A Rebrand Without Receipts

Nothing in the record shows the Democratic National Committee formally adopted this “nice” strategy. Axios described it only as “some Dems’ 2028 strategy,” a plan being weighed by individual candidates, not a party-wide commitment. Until Democrats can show their actual campaign spending matches their soft new language, conservative voters have every reason to view “Make America Nice Again” as little more than a marketing gimmick slapped on the same old playbook of fear-based attack ads and scorched-earth politics.

For a party that spent years branding Republicans as a threat to democracy, flipping a switch to “basic decency” rings hollow when the ad ledgers tell the real story. Conservatives should watch closely whether this rebrand survives contact with an actual governing agenda, or whether it quietly disappears the moment the next tough race heats up.

Sources:

redstate.com, axios.com, ca.news.yahoo.com, cbsnews.com, inquirer.com, nbcnews.com

© theredwire.com 2026. All rights reserved.