Huntington Beach Challenges California’s Sanctuary Law SB 54 Over Local Law Enforcement Cooperation with ICE

"Sanctuary City" sign with palm trees and sky.

Huntington Beach challenges California’s sanctuary law, sparking a legal battle over local law enforcement’s cooperation with ICE.

At a Glance

  • Huntington Beach is suing California over its sanctuary law, SB 54, claiming it’s unconstitutional
  • The lawsuit argues SB 54 hinders law enforcement’s ability to protect communities
  • Mayor Pat Burns cites rising crime rates as justification for the legal challenge
  • California’s Attorney General Rob Bonta is prepared to defend the law vigorously

Huntington Beach Takes on California’s Sanctuary Law

The City of Huntington Beach has initiated a lawsuit against the state of California, challenging the constitutionality of its sanctuary law, SB 54, also known as the California Values Act. This legal action marks a significant escalation in the ongoing debate over immigration enforcement and local law enforcement’s role in cooperating with federal authorities, particularly Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE).

SB 54, enacted in 2017 under then-Governor Jerry Brown’s administration, restricts local and state law enforcement agencies from collaborating with federal immigration authorities. The law was initially seen as a form of resistance against the Trump administration’s strict immigration policies. However, Huntington Beach officials argue that this legislation impedes their ability to maintain public safety effectively.

Mayor’s Concerns Over Public Safety

Huntington Beach Mayor Pat Burns has been vocal about the city’s motivations behind the lawsuit. He argues that the sanctuary law obstructs local law enforcement’s capacity to fully enforce the law and protect the community. Burns points to reported increases in serious crimes as justification for the legal challenge.

“We are fighting the Sanctuary State Law because it obstructs our ability to fully enforce the law and keep our community safe. When the stakes are currently so high, with reports of increases in human trafficking, increases in foreign gangs taking over apartment buildings in the U.S., killing, raping, and committing other violent crimes against our citizens, we need every possible resource available to fight crime, including federal resources.” – Huntington Beach Mayor Pat Burns

The lawsuit seeks declaratory and injunctive relief to invalidate SB 54, arguing that it violates both the U.S. Constitution and federal immigration laws. Huntington Beach’s legal team contends that the law infringes upon the Supremacy Clause and the Naturalization Clause of the Constitution.

State’s Defense of SB 54

California Attorney General Rob Bonta’s office has expressed its commitment to defending SB 54. A spokesperson for Bonta stated that the office is prepared to vigorously defend the law, emphasizing its importance for immigrant communities in California.

“The Attorney General is committed to protecting and ensuring the rights of California’s immigrant communities and upholding vital laws like SB 54. Our office successfully fought back against a challenge to SB 54 by the first Trump administration, and we are prepared to vigorously defend SB 54 again.” a spokesperson for California Attorney General Rob Bonta stated.

This is not the first time SB 54 has faced legal challenges. The Trump administration previously sued California over the law, but that challenge was struck down in court. However, Huntington Beach’s lawsuit introduces new arguments and cites specific instances where the law allegedly compromised public safety.

Implications for Other California Cities

The lawsuit filed by Huntington Beach could have far-reaching implications for other cities and counties in California. Legal experts suggest that some local governments may consider defying the California Values Act if Huntington Beach’s challenge proves successful.

City Attorney Michael Gates describes the lawsuit as “incredibly strong,” highlighting the city’s determination to see the case through. The complaint includes examples from Orange County where compliance with SB 54 allegedly led to the release of inmates with ICE detainers who were subsequently rearrested for new crimes.

As this legal battle unfolds, it underscores the ongoing tension between state and local governments over immigration policy. The outcome of this case could potentially reshape the landscape of sanctuary policies in California and influence similar debates across the nation.

Sources:

  1. California Slapped With Lawsuit Over ‘Unconstitutional’ Sanctuary Law |
  2. Huntington Beach sues California over sanctuary state law
  3. California Slapped with Lawsuit Over ‘Unconstitutional’ Sanctuary Law

RELATED ARTICLESMORE FROM AUTHOR